Free Estimates - Click or Call Now
1-888-370-6924
spray foam vs rigid

Spray Foam & Rigid Foam Insulation Comparison

Spray Foam Insulation Installed In Hastings

Best-suited for big jobs. Two-part spray foam provides excellent air sealing and insulation, and is often sprayed against open framing, as in this attic installation.

Remember when a pink panther held the monopoly on home insulation? Those days are gone. Today homeowners, contractors and building scientists (the experts who study home energy performance) spend a lot of time talking about foam insulation. But this newly popular insulation can come in many forms. Right now, let's consider the differences between the spray foam and rigid foam. More specifically, we can compare the closed-cell spray foam that requires two components to be mixed at the application nozzle, and the rigid foam insulation boards that come in different thicknesses.

Both two-component spray foam and rigid foam are useful for improving home energy performance. Sometimes it can be difficult to decide whether spray foam or rigid foam is best for a particular application.

Find out which insulation is right for your home

Insulation is essential for energy efficiency, and nobody knows insulation better than Dr. Energy Saver. Call or email today to arrange for a free estimate for home insulation in Eau Claire, Saint Paul, Cottage Grove, Hastings, Chippewa Falls, and other areas including Menomonie, River Falls, Houlton, Hudson, Farmington, Rosemount, Prescott, and more.

The Pros and Cons of Spray Foam and Rigid Foam Insulation

Two-Component Spray Foam

 

Rigid Foam insulation

Pros:
  • Provides both insulation and air sealing; air sealing is excellent because the foam expands to fill gaps and cracks.
  • High R-value —about R-7 per in. depending on formulation.
  • Speedy installation. Foaming can be done in a fraction of the time it takes to cut, fit, and seal rigid board insulation.
  • Once cured, spray foam insulation stays in place; it won't shift, settle, or fall out of place.
Cons:
  • Messy; overspray can deposit foam where it must be removed.
  • Respirators and protective clothing must be worn during installation.
  • If the area being insulated cannot be isolated from living space, occupants must vacate premises until foam cures – typically two hours.
  • Temperature sensitive; cold temperatures can cause problems with foaming action or curing.
  • R-value can degrade slightly over time.
 
Pros:
  • Provides both insulation and air sealing, provided that seams between foam panels are sealed with tape.
  • Less messy than spray foam.
  • Different thicknesses are available to suit different application & R-value requirements.
  • Panels are easy to cut and can be installed in any temperature.
  • Safe handling; no harmful emissions during installation.
  • Best installation for insulating crawl space and basement walls.
  • Some rigid foam panels (like SilverGlo™, for example) include a radiant barrier for additional energy savings.
Cons:
  • R-value varies based on type of rigid foam. It can be as low as R-3.8 per in. or as high as R-8 per in.
  • More time-consuming installation than spray foam in some (but not all) applications.
  • Sometimes single-component spray foam must be applied around edges of rigid foam to seal and hold panel in place.

Be sure to check out our other content to help in choosing the best spray foam insulation and the best spray foam contractor in Wisconsin and Minnesota.

Start Saving Energy and Money With An Insulation Upgrade

Call 1-888-370-6924 or contact us online to schedule a free estimate for spray foam insulation in Saint Paul, Cottage Grove, Chippewa Falls, Hastings, Eau Claire, Prescott, Houlton, Farmington, Rosemount, Menomonie, Hudson, River Falls, and nearby.

We can also identify the other major areas in your home that are depleting your home's energy. Our home energy audit is a wonderful resource for prioritizing your home's energy upgrades and repairs.

Looking for a price? Get a no cost, no obligation free estimate.

Serving WI and MN including the Greater Eau Clair area
Our Wisconsin and Minnesota Service Area
Cities in Anoka County, MN
Andover
Anoka
Bethel
Blaine
Centerville
Circle Pines
Columbia Heights
Coon Rapids
East Bethel
Fridley
Ham Lake
Lexington
Lino Lakes
Oak Grove
Ramsey
Saint Francis

Cities in Carver County, MN
Carver
Chanhassen
Chaska
Victoria
Waconia

Cities in Chisago County, MN
Center City
Chisago City
Lindstrom
North Branch
Rush City
Stacy
Taylors Falls
Wyoming

Cities in Dakota County, MN
Apple Valley
Eagan
Inver Grove Heights
Lakeville
Lilydale
Mendota
Northfield
Randolph
Rosemount
South Saint Paul
Sunfish Lake
Vermillion
West Saint Paul

Cities in Goodhue County, MN
Cannon Falls
Red Wing

Cities in Hennepin County, MN
Bloomington
Brooklyn Center
Brooklyn Park
Champlin
Corcoran
Crystal Bay
Dayton
Deephaven
Eden Prairie
Edina
Excelsior
Golden Valley
Greenfield
Hanover
Hopkins
Independence
Long Lake
Loretto
Maple Grove
Maple Plain
Medicine Lake
Medina
Minneapolis
Minnestrista
Minnetonka
Minnetonka Beach
Mound
New Hope
Orono
Osseo
Plymouth
Richfield
Robbinsdale
Rockford
Rogers
Saint Anthony
Saint Bonifacius
Saint Louis Park
Shorewood
Spring Park
Tonka Bay
Wayzata
Woodland

Cities in Ramsey County, MN
Arden Hills
Falcon Heights
Lauderdale
Little Canada
Maplewood
Mounds View
New Brighton
North Oaks
North Saint Paul
Roseville
Saint Paul
Shoreview
Spring Lake Park
Vadnais Heights

Cities in Scott County, MN
Prior Lake
Savage
Shakopee

Cities in Washington County, MN
Afton
Bayport
Cottage Grove
Forest Lake
Hastings
Hugo
Lake Elmo
Lake Saint Croix Beach
Lakeland
Landfall
Mahtomedi
Marine On Saint Croix
Newport
Oak Park Heights
Oakdale
Pine Springs
Saint Marys Point
Saint Paul Park
Scandia
Stillwater
White Bear Lake
Woodbury

Cities in Barron County, WI
Barron
Cameron
Chetek
Cumberland
Dallas
Haugen
New Auburn
Prairie Farm
Rice Lake
Turtle Lake

Cities in Buffalo County, WI
Mondovi

Cities in Burnett County, WI
Grantsburg
Siren
Webster

Cities in Chippewa County, WI
Bloomer
Boyd
Cadott
Chippewa Falls
Cornell
Lake Hallie
Stanley

Cities in Dunn County, WI
Boyceville
Colfax
Downing
Elk Mound
Knapp
Menomonie
Ridgeland
Wheeler

Cities in Eau Claire County, WI
Altoona
Augusta
Eau Claire
Fairchild
Fall Creek

Cities in Pepin County, WI
Durand
Pepin
Stockholm

Cities in Pierce County, WI
Bay City
Ellsworth
Elmwood
Maiden Rock
Plum City
Prescott
River Falls
Spring Valley

Cities in Polk County, WI
Balsam Lake
Centuria
Clayton
Clear Lake
Dresser
Frederic
Luck
Milltown
Osceola
Saint Croix Falls

Cities in Saint Croix County, WI
Baldwin
Deer Park
Glenwood City
Hammond
Hudson
New Richmond
Roberts
Somerset
Wilson
Woodville

Cities in St. Croix County, WI
North Hudson
Star Prairie

Our Locations: